AdvertiseDonate
Saturday, November 21, 2026Local news for Maricopa County, Arizona.
Maricopa County Herald · 1910 South Stapley Drive, Mesa, AZ 85204
Politics · Birmingham

GOP Election Trust: Midterm Polling Shows Persistent Doubt

New data reveals a sharp drop in Republican confidence in the 2026 vote count, contrasting with the majority of Americans who viewed the race as fair.

By Molly Harrison ·

Illustration for: GOP Election Trust: Midterm Polling Shows Persistent Doubt
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

For millions of voters in Maricopa County and across the nation, the 2026 midterm elections ended with a clear change in congressional control. While Democrats reclaimed both chambers, a new survey indicates that a large portion of the Republican base still questions the integrity of the process. The gap between the two parties in their perception of the results has widened considerably since the last presidential cycle.

The University of California San Diego released polling data on Friday showing that fewer than half of Republican voters nationwide considered the midterms to be free and fair. Only 52 percent of Republicans said they trusted that votes were counted accurately. This figure marks a steep decline from the 2024 election, when more than 80 percent of Republicans expressed confidence in the vote-counting process after Donald Trump won the presidency.

In contrast, 66 percent of all American adults stated they believe the 2026 midterms were fair. This represents an increase from pre-election estimates, where less than half of U.S. adults expected a fair contest. However, this overall majority is driven largely by Democrats and independents. Many of these voters had previously worried about federal interference at the polls, a scenario that did not materialize.

Thad Kousser, a co-director of UC San Diego's Center for Transparent and Trusted Elections, noted that the distrust is concentrated within one party. "There are still a lot of people who remain unconvinced that they can trust elections," Kousser said. "And they're predominantly located in one [political] party." Lauren Prather, also a co-director of the center, warned that the 66 percent national approval rating can be misleading. She stated that the figure buries the lede regarding the partisan gap in trust.

The current level of skepticism among Republicans is not an entirely new phenomenon, though the magnitude of the shift is notable. Kousser compared the situation to asking people if they trust the referees after an overtime basketball game. He explained that in an ideal scenario, the swing in trust between election cycles should be around 10 percentage points. Instead, the data shows a 30-point swing among Republicans between 2024 and 2026.

Despite the current doubts, the numbers are still an improvement over 2020. According to similar polling from MIT's Election Data and Science Lab, only 22 percent of Republicans had confidence in the nationwide vote count before the January 6, 2021, Capitol riot. This historical context suggests that while trust is lower than in 2024, it has recovered from its recent lows.

The polling also reflects the ongoing political narrative surrounding election integrity. When asked if politicians discuss voter fraud too much, too little, or just right, only 15 percent of Republicans answered that the discussion is excessive. Kousser observed that there is a demand within the Republican base for continued focus on the issue, and politicians continue to supply that narrative. This dynamic creates a sustained market for these concerns among the party's voters.

More Politics · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Maricopa County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Maricopa County, Arizona. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Maricopa County Herald in your inboxLocal news for Maricopa County, Arizona. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.